Multimedia/Recordings
Interdisciplinary one-day seminar as part of the Heidelberg University Lectures summer semester 2012
The ruling of the Cologne Regional Court on the circumcision of boys (case no. 151 Ns 169/11) has triggered a broad debate. It is not only the different positions that are remarkable, but also the dynamics that this topic unleashes. The debate and some of the statements made by its participants show how little understanding there still is within our society about its own present and future and how the idea of tolerance is increasingly dwindling. In the meantime, politicians have also spoken out, but their half-hearted proposals do not yet hold out the prospect of a consensual solution.
What is needed is an open, serious and informed debate. This is why - as an additional event as part of its "Heidelberg University Lectures on Society in Transition" - the Heidelberg University of Jewish Studies, in cooperation with the Central Council of Jews in Germany, hosted a one-day seminar on July 22, 2012, at which academics and experts from society, science and politics had their say in an interdisciplinary exchange (all videos on YouTube).
I. History and culture - antiquity, the Middle Ages, modern times
PD Dr. Andreas Brämer, Hamburg Tradition and reform: The circumcision debates around 1850
Prof. Dr. Birgit Klein, Heidelberg Circumcision, inner-Jewish criticism and gender aspects
II Law and rights
PD Dr. Edward Schramm, Freiburg Circumcision from a criminal law perspective
PD Dr. Benjamin Jokisch, Hamburg Sharia and Halacha in Germany - A departure into legal pluralism?
III History and culture - contemporary history and the present
Prof. Dr. Daniel Krochmalnik, Heidelberg Brith Mila and Shoa
Prof. Dr. Anat Feinberg, Heidelberg The motif of circumcision in Hebrew literature
IV. Medicine, religion and life practice
Rabbi Dr. med. Antje Yael Deusel, Bamberg Medical aspects of circumcision
Prof. Dr. Michael Bongardt, Berlin Law and rites: A philosophical and ethical balancing of interests